✦ AI-Generated Answer

Between Etsy and Gumroad, Etsy has higher AI visibility with a score of 74/100 vs 19/100. Etsy is mentioned in 11/15 prompts while Gumroad appears in 2/15. GoAI analyzes how often AI assistants such as ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini recommend a brand across real buyer prompts.

AI Recommendation Comparison

Etsy vs Gumroad

Which E-Commerce Platform brand dominates AI recommendations?

Winner

Etsy

E-Commerce Platform

74/100

Competitive

Mentions: 11/15

Voice: 45%

Sentiment: Positive

✓ ChatGPT ✓ Claude ✗ Perplexity ✓ Gemini

Full analysis →

Gumroad

E-Commerce Platform

19/100

Invisible

Mentions: 2/15

Voice: 13%

Sentiment: Neutral

✓ ChatGPT ✗ Claude ✗ Perplexity ✓ Gemini

Full analysis →

Etsy has a higher AI visibility score, meaning AI assistants recommend it more frequently.

Signal Comparison

Entity Mention Frequency

Etsy81
Gumroad23

Content Citability

Etsy59
Gumroad33

Third-Party Authority

Etsy63
Gumroad19

Structured Data

Etsy80
Gumroad12

Content Freshness

Etsy75
Gumroad23

Competitive Narrative

Etsy75
Gumroad16

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Etsy or Gumroad recommended more by AI?

Etsy has a higher AI Visibility Score (74/100) compared to Gumroad (19/100).

Which platforms recommend Etsy?

Etsy is mentioned on: ChatGPT (5 mentions), Claude (5 mentions), Gemini (1 mentions).

How were these scores calculated?

GoAI tests brands across 4 AI platforms using buyer-intent prompts relevant to the E-Commerce Platform category.

Check your brand's AI visibility

Scan Your Brand Free →

Free scan · No signup · Takes 30 seconds

Best E-Commerce Platform → · AI Visibility Index →