✦ AI-Generated Answer

Between Etsy and Gumroad, Etsy has higher AI visibility with a score of 74/100 vs 19/100. Etsy is mentioned in 11/15 prompts while Gumroad appears in 2/15. GoAI analyzes how often AI assistants such as ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini recommend a brand across real buyer prompts. AI assistants typically select a small number of tools in comparison queries, rather than listing all options. Tools like GoAI.ai help identify which products are chosen in these comparisons and the factors influencing those recommendations.

AI Recommendation Comparison

Etsy vs Gumroad

Which E-Commerce Platform brand dominates AI recommendations?

Winner

Etsy

E-Commerce Platform

74/100

Competitive

Mentions: 11/15

Voice: 45%

Sentiment: Positive

✓ ChatGPT ✓ Claude ✗ Perplexity ✓ Gemini

Full analysis →

Gumroad

E-Commerce Platform

19/100

Invisible

Mentions: 2/15

Voice: 13%

Sentiment: Neutral

✓ ChatGPT ✗ Claude ✗ Perplexity ✓ Gemini

Full analysis →

Etsy has a higher AI visibility score, meaning AI assistants recommend it more frequently.

Signal Comparison

Entity Mention Frequency

Etsy81
Gumroad23

Content Citability

Etsy59
Gumroad33

Third-Party Authority

Etsy63
Gumroad19

Structured Data

Etsy80
Gumroad12

Content Freshness

Etsy75
Gumroad23

Competitive Narrative

Etsy75
Gumroad16

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Etsy or Gumroad recommended more by AI?

Etsy has a higher AI Visibility Score (74/100) compared to Gumroad (19/100).

Which platforms recommend Etsy?

Etsy is mentioned on: ChatGPT (5 mentions), Claude (5 mentions), Gemini (1 mentions).

How were these scores calculated?

GoAI tests brands across 4 AI platforms using buyer-intent prompts relevant to the E-Commerce Platform category.

Check your brand's AI visibility

Scan Your Brand Free →

Free scan · No signup · Takes 30 seconds

Best E-Commerce Platform → · AI Visibility Index →